The Irish Setter Marshall 11" Waterproof Steel Toe Pull-On is a tall wellington-style work boot from Red Wing's Irish Setter line. It combines a steel toe, EH protection and waterproofing with a Goodyear welt, so it can be resoled.
We haven't worn the Marshall ourselves. This review is based on Irish Setter's published specs, authorized retailer listings and buyer feedback. You'll see what it does well, where it falls short, and who should pick something else.
Quick Verdict
Buy it if you want a waterproof, resoleable steel toe pull-on for ranch, farm, oilfield or general outdoor work, and you like boots you can step into without laces.
Skip it if you need lots of ankle support for ladders and rough ground, you work in deep cold (it isn't insulated), or you're on a tight budget.
Check the current price of the Irish Setter Marshall on Amazon
Irish Setter Marshall Specs
| Spec | Irish Setter Marshall 11" Steel Toe Pull-On |
|---|---|
| Height | 11 inches |
| Upper | Full-grain waterproof oiled and waxed leather |
| Safety toe | Steel, ASTM F2413 I/C |
| Electrical hazard | EH rated |
| Waterproofing | UltraDry waterproof system |
| Construction | Goodyear welt (resoleable) |
| Outsole | Rubber roper-style outsole, slip resistant, heat resistant (HRO, 475°F) |
| Footbed | Removable polyurethane |
| Shank | Steel |
| Insulation | None |
| Widths | Regular (D) and Wide (EE) |
Specs from Irish Setter's product pages and authorized retailers. Irish Setter sells the Marshall under several style numbers and colors, so check the Amazon listing for the exact version.
What the Marshall Does Well
Tall, waterproof coverage
An 11-inch waterproof shaft roughly doubles the wade height of a 6-inch boot. That's useful in mud, creek crossings, wash bays and wet pastures. Buyers often say the waterproofing holds up, with some reporting dry feet after a full year.
Resoleable Goodyear welt
Most pull-on work boots in this class are cemented. The Marshall's Goodyear welt means a cobbler can replace the sole, which stretches the life of a pricier boot.
Heat-resistant outsole
The outsole is rated heat resistant, which helps around hot pavement, welding sparks and hot equipment. For more heat-ready options, see our pull-on boots for welders.
Comfortable for many out of the box
Buyers often praise the cushioning and say the fit felt right from the start. Some even mention the boot breathes better than they expected.
Where It Falls Short
Stiff when new
Some buyers say the boots are hard to pull on at first and the steel toe causes soreness early on. Wear them for short periods during the first week.
Fit depends on sizing alone
There are no laces, so heel hold comes down to the right size. Expect a little heel slip when new. If the heel slips a lot, the size is wrong.
Less ankle support than a lacer
Pull-ons can't be tightened around the ankle. If you climb ladders or work on steep, uneven ground, a lace-up boot is more stable.
Not insulated
The Marshall has no insulation. For cold winter work, see our best winter work boots.
Pricey
It's well above budget pull-ons. You pay for the welt, the waterproofing and the brand.
Sizing Tips
Most buyers say the Marshall fits true to size and width. Try it with your work socks, and make sure your longest toe clears the steel cap when you stand. A little heel slip is normal at first. Choose Wide (EE) if you usually need wide boots.
Pull-On vs Lace-Up: Which Should You Get?
| Pull-on (Marshall) | Lace-up | |
|---|---|---|
| On and off | Fast | Slower |
| Ankle support | Less | More, adjustable |
| Debris and sparks | No laces to catch or burn | Laces can catch |
| Best for | Ranch, farm, mud, welding | Ladders, rough ground |
Comparing pull-ons? See our best wellington work boots and our Ariat WorkHog XT review.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Irish Setter Marshall waterproof?
Yes. It uses Irish Setter's UltraDry waterproof system with waterproof leather.
Is the Marshall steel toe EH rated?
Yes. The steel toe meets ASTM F2413, and the boot is EH rated.
Can you resole the Irish Setter Marshall?
Yes. It has Goodyear welt construction.
Is the Marshall insulated?
No. It's an uninsulated boot, best for three-season work.
Does the Marshall run true to size?
Most buyers say yes. Fit matters more with a pull-on, so check the return terms before you buy.
The Bottom Line
The Irish Setter Marshall is a waterproof, resoleable steel toe pull-on that suits wet outdoor work. It's stiff at first, not insulated, and offers less ankle support than a lace-up.
If you want a tall pull-on built to last, check the Irish Setter Marshall on Amazon. For more picks, see our best work boots roundup.
